Changes to Childcare-For Parents

Dear Parents

I am a parent of two boys and an early years specialist and have worked within the early years sector for over twenty –six years.

I am writing to you because I want to raise your attention to a government proposal that might affect your child’s learning and development opportunities if you use childcare.

You may have heard that the Minister for Childcare, Ms Truss, is proposing changing the adult to child ratios in early years settings. For daycare settings this will mean that for your children who are aged two – three there will be one adult for six children and within home based settings childminders  will be able to have up to four children aged five and under.

The majority of early years settings, academics and experts are against these higher ratios as, like me, they care about your children and the negative impact this will have on their learning and development. One provider said to me recently. “This will be like conveyor belt childcare, there will be poor interactions and it will not be quality care.” She went on to add, “We currently operate below ratio in our baby room with one adult to two babies (current legal requirement one adult to three babies), I believe this is what babies need and parents sending their child to my setting also agree. Mark my word, I will not be changing my ratio, irrespective of what the Government says. The proposed French Ecole Maternelle seems more adult directed, with children sitting still for long periods of time and from what we know about child development, children learn through, play, exploring and investigating their environment.”  Via social media, there have been providers who also echo this statement that they will not be changing their ratios. Hence, their fees will remain the same.

Unfortunately, if these proposals go ahead, it will create a two-tier system with parents making impossibly difficult decisions regarding their child’s care; do they pay more for more adults or pay less for less adults?

Every child deserves the best start in their early years regardless of their parent’s ability to pay. This is my professional opinion and research indeed informs us that this is so and that quality childcare with adults, who are able to give children positive interactions, ensures that children do better in the long term.

The Government should not be even considering changing the ratios as a way to get more parents into work and thinking that this will make quality childcare cheaper.

Young children need attention and ‘snuggle in’ times, with staff who are tuned into their personal needs. The more children in an adult’s care the fewer opportunities there will be for this. I remember when I worked directly with two year olds, especially when they woke up from a sleep and needing time to ‘come around’ and so rightly needed ‘snuggle in’ time; I cannot even imagine being able to ‘snuggle’ with six two year olds. Note, that Ms Truss also proposes that if a practitioner is a graduate they should be able to look after more children but he or she won’t have any more arms for snuggling!

Ms Truss is to be commended in looking at the childcare sector and the range of issues that impact on you as parents, providers, staff and your children.

However I believe that Ms Truss needs to press the pause button and continue with the debate to identify solutions and to speak with providers; primarily looking at what the Government do indeed spend on childcare, how they can reduce any unnecessary spending and making sure that the sector is funded appropriately, in order to make quality childcare affordable to you.

I would therefore ask you to the support the sector with this and make your concerns heard, via writing to Ms Truss and your local MP.

Please can I direct you to this petition that has been set up against the increase in ratios.

Click on the link to sign:

Important research: … …

Thanks in advance

Laura Henry

Managing Director

Childcare Consultancy

CC: Ms Truss

24 thoughts on “Changes to Childcare-For Parents

  1. They should be considering reducing the number if children childminders can have alone. I do think the ratios can be increased. There is no difference in accidents or care evidenced by reducing the ratios from 5 to 4.
    How do childminders manage all these cuddles when caring for different ages children at the same time.

  2. Well said Laura. We will echo your sentiments in our February newsletter to parents next week. Over 1000 signatures already shows that these feelings are shared by many. This is an unacceptable proposal and we have a moral obligation to stand up for quality on behalf of our youngest children.

  3. I am a childminder. I look after 2 18-month olds, a 2 1/2 year old and three primary school going children (between 5 and 6). I work alone. I work hard to meet all the needs of all the children I look after, quite successfully I think. However, if I were to suddenly be able to have 3 more under 5 year olds, both logistically and developmentally it would be a nightmare (buggies, feeding, one to one attention). The only way it would work would be to take on an assistant or two, which would mean turning my house into a mini nursery. I have no problem with this (although I quite like my house the way it is), but i do realise that if many minders go down this route, it is possible that accidents and bad practice could happen. So long as Ofsted and / or other government bodies have the man power and skill to make sure the childcare provision is of the highest standard, then no problem. The last thing we need is another case of Vanessa George..

  4. Hi laura, was on the supervision course with you recently in twickenham! I remember you talking about this.

    Its absurd and i truly hope, for children are our future. That they do not do this. Children should be exposed to an educating, caring, nurturing and loving environment – this cannot be achieved with this change!!

    • As, with most Scandinavia countries, children, within the early years, from birth to seven, have the opportunity to learn through play. There is a strong focus on promoting outdoor play, which impacts positively on children’s learning and development. Even though, these children start formal school later, research informs us that these children do better academically in the long term. In the UK, children start school, far too early and developmental they are not ready. Hence, we set them up to fail in the long term. :-)

  5. As a Director of 2 Day Care Nurseries and North East Childcare Training I cannot agree with you more Laura. The sector has enough problems with funding and making it acceptable for a care and education provider no matter how well qualified, as all my staff are, to be responsible for looking after an absurd amount of very young children makes me shudder. I am sure with the free funding for 2 year olds arriving parents will be banging on the door to have one adult look after 6 of them alone. Not in my establishment. I will not be budging on ratios despite the financial problems we face with cuts. I honestly cannot imagine many parents prepared to do this.

  6. Hi Laura, asa freelance early years inspector for Tribal, a Pre-school Chair and a Mum blogger, I heartily support your open letter and petition, and would be intrigued to know more about your work… Regards,

  7. Pingback: Changes to Childcare – what it means to you! | Sue Atkins

  8. my 18 month old son has just started nursery and I for one would not be happy with the proposed new ratio changes especially for 0-2 years!

  9. my 18 month old son has just started nursery and I for one would not be happy with the proposed new ratio changes especially for 0-2 years! its madness

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s